Why CRM implementation requires company-wide engagement
Successful CRM implementation takes a lot more than cash and technical savvy to get right. If it’s going to bring transparency to all your processes, your whole business will need a say in its conception
When Brighton-based business TCMM Shutter Group had ambitions to grow its £10m a year turnover, leaders knew it had to leave its spreadsheet-based business model behind. The bespoke blinds company kept all customer quotes, client details and feedback on multiple sheets which was messy, time-consuming and led to duplications. Sam Tamlyn, operations director at TCMM says: “We had to keep hiring people just to keep on top of the data.”
However, making the wrong choice in a customer relationship management platform (CRM) – especially for a business which already has an existing customer base – can be disastrous. Twenty years ago, British Airways onboarded a CRM called Ocean Wave. Its complex data structure made it difficult for staff to understand and – even then – the data quality it provided was not useful enough for the analysis team. This created more work while negatively affecting sales.
For TCMM, adopting Workbooks allowed the company to double in size without doubling its workforce. Tamlyn says: “We can see how many appointments we are getting in, how long they will take to fulfil, how many quotes we have waiting for responses. CRM has helped us a lot in terms of errors.”
“A CRM purchase should be done holistically”
Amanda AI is a platform that can create, budget, and run whole advertising campaigns for SMEs using artificial intelligence. When it wanted to invest in its own CRM system it knew its online-only, customer-oriented business would be affected by any missteps. Choosing a CRM that suited every sector of the business was like choosing a restaurant for a large group of friends, says chief technical officer Torkel Ohman.
“Some of your friends will say location is the most important aspect, some will say food, some will say the price – and they all have valid points. The same goes for a CRM, there is a lot of different functionality and which tool you use depends on what functionality you are mainly looking for. When choosing CRM consider how much customer data you want to use and what other systems you want to integrate with and also things like lead management, marketing automation and pipeline.”
A holistic approach that unites the CRM needs of all areas of your business from factory floor to sales to distribution is essential. It may be tempting to think that CRM is the solution to all of your business growth problems but that is rarely the case without top-to-bottom input, says Helen Ashton, CEO of Shape Beyond and former CFO of Asos, when the online giant went through various technical evolutions.
A CRM is most effective when it serves a business' needs
“Business leaders need to make sure that all people impacted by change are involved at the earliest appropriate stage in the discussion. Technology can’t solve the problems that inefficient processes create alone; businesses should review their processes, or any software can only help to do the wrong thing faster," says John Cheney, CEO of Workbooks.
Companies shouldn’t just use a CRM to inspect staff and sales, but to expose logjams and improve flow. According to a 2018 report by Harvard Business Review, the principle reason for CRM failure is they are used for monitoring rather than improving processes. The study said: “CRM systems are too often used for inspection – to report on progress, improve the accuracy of forecasts, provide visibility, predict project delivery dates, and provide a range of other business intelligence – rather than creating improvement in the sales process.”
“CRM can accelerate growth in your business, but can do the exact opposite if used incorrectly”
In 1999, Hershey, one of the largest chocolate manufacturers in the world, invested over $110m in a new CRM system. However, it got its timing spectacularly wrong. Launched during Halloween, its busiest sales period, the CRM caused a logjam in Hershey’s existing systems and immediately stalled orders worth $100m to its customers, causing an almost 20% drop in quarterly profits.
“It’s important to remember that the business’ objective isn’t to buy software, but to achieve a business outcome that the software should enable,” says Cheney. “Focusing on outcomes should also lower the cost and risk of its CRM project.” When a business doesn’t know what outcomes it wants to achieve with CRM technology, it should discuss this with the vendor, says Cheney. This is a key indicator of the vendor’s ability to help with the business’ objectives, rather than simply to supply software.
Choosing a CRM that suited every sector of the business was like choosing a restaurant for a large group of friends
Understanding how a business will be changed by the arrival of the new technology should be factored into the decision-making process. Factors like customer lifetime value, churn rate, upselling and customer acquisition cost might also apply to your decision, says Ohman: “A way of measuring how happy your customers are with your product or service is also something you should measure. Since it’s a soft value that can’t be converted to revenue you might view it as a soft impact on your company, but it’s still a very important metric to track over time.”
“Invest and plan with CRM in your future”
In Ashton’s experience at Asos and JD Sports, the cost of a new CRM system is not often offset in the short- to medium-term by increased revenue alone. Often it is the underlying process that requires a review and refresh rather than the technology itself before rewards are seen, she says.
“I’ve seen most benefits where SMEs shift from a basic, often home-grown CRM facility, to one of the mainstream providers. That is, provided the new technology isn't over specced or implemented poorly.”
Business leaders need to make sure that all people impacted by change are involved at the earliest appropriate stage in the discussion. Technology can’t solve the problems that ineffective processes create
As businesses migrate to the cloud, implementation becomes easier, but CRM technology is continually evolving and – like upgrading warehouse machinery – it requires a long-term investment. A successful investment will not only implement the CRM that works for their business today, but also consider how it will work with their team of tomorrow, says Ohman.
“Scaling and cost are always things to consider. Would you buy the same tool if your team was double the size? A tool that might be perfect for a smaller team might not be viable when you grow. It might be better to go with the tool adapted for the bigger teams straight away than to spend money on a tool, implementation and integration only to switch it out in one or two years.”
Successful implementation requires holistic involvement from across the business to get right, but if achieved, it can have a lasting impact on a company’s success.